PROVIDENCE – An emergency movement for a short lived restraining order and preliminary injunction involving a r participant has been denied in Windfall Superior Court docket.
Friars midfielder Cameron Yriondo was searching for y from the NCAA in accordance with the group's amended bylaws, which had been formally adopted Aug. 1. Choose Sarah Taft-Carter within the case Wednesday, Sept. 30.
"The court docket acknowledges his achievements and is sympathetic towards him due to the implications of this determination," Taft-Carter wrote. "Nevertheless, after an entire evaluation, this court docket concludes that plaintiff’s emergency movement for a short lived restraining order and preliminary injunction is denied."
Yriondo sought a fifth season of eligibility below the NCAA's amended bylaws, which had been formally adopted forward of the 2026-27 tutorial 12 months. The rule modifications provide a 5-in-5 interval for student-athletes starting with the Class of 2023 – 5 years of eligibility for student-athletes over 5 calendar years. The NCAA eradicated exemptions or extra years for redshirts, medical waivers and hardship waivers with the creation of the brand new tips.
"(Yriondo) exhausted his eligibility after enjoying within the 2025-26 season below the 4-Seasons-in-5-Years Rule," Taft-Carter wrote. "As a result of the 5-Yr Interval of Eligibility didn’t confer eligibility onto plaintiff, he has failed to determine an inexpensive chance of success on the deserves of his breach of contract declare."
Yriondo performed for Division II Seattle Pacific within the 2022 and 2023 seasons earlier than a switch to Virginia. He spent 2024 with the Cavaliers earlier than a transfer to Windfall, the place he began in 14 of 16 appearances with the Friars in 2025. Yriondo is listed as a graduate scholar on the present roster and is pursuing a grasp's diploma in enterprise administration.
Yriondo performed in Windfall's opening match of the season, a 4-1 residence win over Sacred Coronary heart. He began within the midfield and recorded an help on the opening objective for the Friars. Yriondo additionally recorded a lone shot on objective.
Yriondo didn’t play in Windfall's following match, a 3-2 defeat at Quinnipiac on Aug. 24. The interval between these conferences with the Pioneers and Bobcats included a federal district court docket choose in Colorado staying a preliminary injunction granting Class of 2022 athletes a fifth 12 months of eligibility. Wisne v. NCAA was filed in July and alleged antitrust violations.
Taft-Carter's ruling stated Yriondo explored his skilled choices in Spain on the shut of the 2025-26 tutorial 12 months however didn’t signal a contract with any membership. He was contacted by Windfall coach t after the Wisne injunction was issued and accepted a proposal to return to the Friars for a second season. Yriondo started practising with the crew in early August and was deemed match to take the pitch for the opener.
Yriondo filed his criticism towards the NCAA in early September, alleging 4 counts – breach of contract, breach of implied covenant of fine religion and truthful dealing, arbitrary and capricious motion by a voluntary athletic affiliation and declaratory judgement. The NCAA filed its opposition on Sept. 15, and Yriondo adopted with a pair of supplemental memorandums previous to the choice.
"The hurt alleged by plaintiff is his incapacity to play soccer at a excessive stage," Taft-Carter wrote. "Plaintiff competed in 4 seasons of collegiate soccer. On the conclusion of the 2025-26 season, he had exhausted his eligibility. He was subsequently ineligible to play within the 2026-27 season.
"As he was ineligible below the earlier 4-Seasons-in-5-Years Rule, he remained ineligible below the 5-Yr Interval of Eligibility Bylaw. Moreover, plaintiff concedes he exhausted his eligibility and commenced exploring a chance to proceed his soccer profession overseas.
"The advantages of competitors can not solely be conferred by way of collegiate competitors. Plaintiff acknowledged this sentiment in searching for non-collegiate alternatives after he exhausted his eligibility. Moreover, plaintiff’s continued aspirations are speculative. Right here, plaintiff has not demonstrated that he’ll endure irreparable hurt upon the denial of his movement."
This ruling may set up precedent for related circumstances elsewhere within the state. l are nonetheless awaiting a ruling on the same submitting made in Washington County Superior Court docket. Taft-Carter was the presiding choose in that case when it was first heard in September.
Windfall additionally has s practising with the crew who can be ineligible with out being granted a fifth 12 months. South Florida guard Joseph Pinion and Saint Joseph's guard Derek Simpson have but to pursue a authorized possibility and, in keeping with Thursday feedback by Friars coach Bryan Hodgson, are at the moment continuing with NCAA.
m
On X: @BillKoch25
This text initially appeared on The Windfall Journal: I